Link: University of Iowa
Roy J. and Lucille A. Carver College of Medicine

information for

information about

Portrait

Timothy H. Holtz, M.D., M.P.H.

'91 M.D.
Medical Officer and Epidemiologist in Tuberculosis Elimination at Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, Atlanta, Georgia

Commander, United States Public Health Service

What is your hometown?

I was born in Chicago, IL, but was raised in Ames, Iowa. I graduated from Ames High School in 1982, and attended St. Olaf College in Minnesota.

How/when did you become interested in science and medicine?

My interest in science is long standing, as my father was a math teacher and from early on instilled in me an interest in scientific inquiry. I took all the honors level courses I could in high school, and decided to major in chemistry in college. While in college, I spent a summer working in a Palo Alto laboratory making monoclonal antibodies, and I decided my career was not headed toward laboratory science. I was too interested in being out in the field, interacting with different people and hearing about their health problems. St. Olaf College has a strong pre-medical track, as well as a strong chemistry department, and in my second year I choose pre-medicine much to the consternation of my chemistry professors. But I felt it opened up many more possibilities for the future.

What interested you to pursue a career in medicine and medical education?

When I was younger my parents had several friends who were physicians, who probably put the idea in my head that I could become a doctor. One otolaryngologist in particular had traveled the world, and spoke quietly but wisely about the health problems in developing countries. After deciding against a career in chemistry I went full steam ahead with pre-med studies, and minored in religion. I had heard medical schools were looking for well rounded individuals, and coming from a liberal arts college it wasn’t hard to take courses in literature, religion, and music. I finished my pre-med requirements after 3 years, and spent my senior year traveling around the world on a study abroad program. It was then that I decided to do international health as a career. I couldn’t get enough of traveling.

Please highlight your major career achievements, awards, discoveries, etc.

I suppose the first thing that my colleagues and I accomplished was forming a non-governmental organization that works for social justice, health, and human rights in developing countries. We call the organization Doctors for Global Health, but it is really a very inclusive group that includes all health professionals, teachers, computer programmers, and others. We are in our 12th year of operation, and now have projects running in El Salvador, Nicaragua, Mexico, Peru, Uganda, and the United States. Due to work constraints I am no longer a board member, but I remain involved with the organization.

Then, during my first few years with the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC), we performed a study in Malawi that showed that the social marketing strategy to get insecticide treated bed nets out into the community to prevent malaria transmission was not working. The cost of the bed nets was too high for the poor to afford. This, and other work, led to an international consensus to make bed nets part of a primary care package for the poor, just as vaccines and Tuberculosis (TB) care are free.

Thirdly, probably the work with the biggest impact has been engaging internationally against drug-resistant TB. I was part of a small CDC/World Health Organization team that established the evidence base for the working definitions of the newly coined “extensively drug-resistant TB,” or XDR TB. The acronym popped into my head one day while I was thinking of the X-Games and the X-Files…we’ve been accused of trying to “sex up” the normally stale world of international TB control, but it worked! The identification that XDR TB leads to much worse treatment outcomes than multidrug-resistant TB has led to a huge increase in attention and funding for TB control globally, which will hopefully make a difference in the lives of millions.

Lastly, I was proud to serve the United States Public Health Service during the World Trade Center and anthrax attacks in 2001, both of which I was intimately involved in.

Is there a teacher, mentor or Carver College of Medicine faculty member who has helped shape your education?

I remember Drs. Richard Wenzel and Mary Nettleman very well. They both sponsored an elective in hospital infections when I was a senior, and I wrote a couple papers with both of them on traveler’s health and surgical wound infections. They probably did more than anyone else in cultivating my interest in epidemiology and public health. Dr. Wenzel was the first person to suggest the CDC’s Epidemic Intelligence Service (EIS) as a possible career move. I filed that in the back of my brain for many years, and it was only after working in primary care medicine for five years that I recalled his advice and applied to EIS. I was glad I did, because it was the best two years of my professional career.

How or why did you choose the University of Iowa for your education and medical training?

I was reared in Iowa, and felt the need to stay close to home. In the end, it was my “travel bug” that took me out of Iowa to do my residency training, but when I reminisce about living in Iowa City, I recall how cosmopolitan it really was if one looked hard enough. The education was excellent, and the learning environment was very safe and nurturing. I am glad to be a graduate of the school; I still keep in touch with many friends from that time.

What kind of professional opportunities or advantages has your University of Iowa medical training provided?

Although we all “dissed” the public health and statistics classes during medical school, it’s ironic that I would ultimately end up in the field of preventive medicine and public health. The training we received in public health was truly excellent, much better than most other students get at other schools. Taking electives with the epidemiologists at the University of Iowa covertly launched me toward a career in public health that I don’t regret for one minute. I’m glad to see that there is now a school of public health at University of Iowa- it was long overdue.

Please describe your professional interests.

No matter what specific field I’ll work in within public health, it will likely always revolve around diseases of the poor and marginalized. I think it’s a crime that there is so much wealth in the world, the “have’s”, and yet so much avoidable suffering among the “have-nots.” The diseases that afflict the poor are not just infectious diseases; diabetes and heart disease are on the increase. Thus my interest in fulfilling what the World Health Organization calls “creating the conditions in which persons can reach the highest attainable standard of health.”

What are some of your outside interests?

Besides learning about health and medicine, what really drove me to travel was photography. I had envisioned applying to become a National Geographic photographer, but that lifestyle does not afford the security that working in the health field does. For several years I was showing my photographs of landscapes and people in small venues, and was selling out my shows. But my free time has slipped away since then, and with small children one never has much time to pursue outside interests very much.

I also enjoy writing, and hopefully will soon publish my book of stories about living and working in India in the 1990’s with the Tibetans in exile. The book will be called “A Doctor in Little Lhasa” or something similar. It’s a short memoir of being a doctor to the Tibetan diaspora in a small Himalayan refugee town, living near to the Dalai Lama, as well as taking care of all the foreigners who flock there to see him. My other interests are hiking and camping, and it was a great place to do that.

Do you have an insight or philosophy that guides you in your professional work?

I’m a firm believer that the right to medical care and to “health” in general, is a right of being human. By “health” I mean the conditions necessary for people to be healthy. The preamble to the World Health Organizations’ Constitution states that “the enjoyment of the highest attainable standard of health is one of the fundamental rights of every human being.” I think this more than anything keeps me going in my job and keeps me striving to do better.

If you could change one thing about the practice or business of medicine, what would it be?

I would take the profit motive out of medicine. I believe that health care is a human right, and that people should not profit on the misfortune or ill health of others. Health care professionals need to make a living of course, but they can do so while working in a humane society that guarantees medical care to all those living within it. The pharmaceutical industry and for-profit health care corporations are sucking an enormous amount of resources out of the system purely for the benefit of their shareholders, while millions of people go without access to medical care in this country. In my opinion it’s really quite shameful. I’ve been active in Physicians for a National Health Program since I was a resident at Cambridge Hospital (a chief reason I trained there), working toward a single-payer health system in the United States that preserves the autonomy of physicians and allows freedom of choice for patients and families. We’re a great country, and creating this kind of system is not outside the realm of our ingenuity.

What is the biggest change you've experienced in medicine since you were a student?

The growth of the health care system’s bureaucracy, and the amount of oversight and management that is being imposed upon practitioners. I practiced primary care medicine for four years in urban Boston in the late 1990’s, and I saw the changes that managed care brought to the field of medicine. Some changes were for the better, but a great number of things got worse. Guaranteeing that diabetic patients have a regular hemoglobin A1C and a foot exam is an important thing, but imposing incentives on physicians is not the right way to do it. European countries have excellent health care systems and much better health indicators that the United States without all the perverse incentives. We’re all in this together, and the system should reflect that communal effort.

What one piece of advice would you give to today's medical students?

Be a dreamer and an idealist, and don’t succumb to the pressures of money making and business. Resist ties to industry and profit. There is so much suffering in the world, and each one of us can make a difference in our own small way and lead a comfortable life for our families. HIV/AIDS, TB, and malaria still kill millions of people around the world each year, and the knowledge of how to treat and prevent these diseases is out there. We need more human power to go and relieve the suffering of the poor and marginalized, both abroad and at home.

What do you see as "the future" of the medicine?

I look at the practice of medicine and public health through a global lens. Despite impressive gains and a large influx of resources into the field of international health, there are still huge challenges ahead.

contact

University of Iowa
Roy J. and Lucille A. Carver College of Medicine
200 CMAB
Iowa City, IA 52242-2600
(319) 335-6707